About CHSA · Editorial standards
Editorial standards
Every claim we make should be checkable. These are the rules our writers, editors and reviewers follow.
Draft for counsel review — not yet in effect. This is a working draft. Counsel has not reviewed it and CHSA’s board has not adopted it, so it does not yet bind CHSA or anyone else.
Independence
- Our editorial team decides what we publish. Funders and anyone affiliated with a cannabis business never see our content before it is published, and they have no say in it.
- No one can pay for, sponsor or direct a CHSA article, alert, recall listing, Verify page or position.
- We don’t run paid advertising, sponsored content or affiliate links.
- CHSA does not test, certify or endorse products or retailers.
See governance and funding for how this is enforced.
How we label content
Every article carries a label. Only safety alerts and CHSA positions use solid labels, so advocacy always looks different from education.
- Safety alert
- A current risk you should act on, based on an official source.
- Explainer
- How something works: testing, labels, rules. Neutral education.
- Research explained
- What a study or review found, and how strong the evidence is.
- Policy watch
- What a law or rule change does. Neutral; no position taken.
- CHSA position
- What CHSA thinks should happen. Advocacy, clearly marked as ours.
Sources and dates
- Every number has a source and a date. If we can’t source it, we don’t publish it.
- We use primary sources first: laws, regulations, regulator pages, official data and peer-reviewed research.
- Sources are numbered on each page and listed at the bottom, with the date we checked them.
- Health and regulatory pages show when they were last checked and when they are next due. Pages past their review date show a warning.
- We quote recall and enforcement notices word for word and link to the official notice.
Evidence levels
When we rate evidence, the rating applies to one specific claim, not to a whole page. The meter uses one color and always comes with a text label.
-
Strong evidence
What this means
We are confident. New research is unlikely to change this.
Usually based on: Consistent results from several well-designed studies or systematic reviews, or the text of a law or regulation.
-
Moderate evidence
What this means
This is probably right, but new research could change the details.
Usually based on: Good-quality studies mostly agree, but they have limits, such as size, length or who was studied.
-
Limited evidence
What this means
Early or mixed evidence. Treat it as a possibility, not a conclusion.
Usually based on: A few small studies, studies that disagree, or mainly lab, animal or case reports.
-
Insufficient evidence
What this means
We don’t know yet. There isn’t enough evidence to say either way.
Usually based on: Little or no research, or only expert opinion and personal stories.
Review and sign-off
- Health content is reviewed by a named, qualified reviewer before it is final. Their name and credentials appear in the “About this information” box on the page, with their conflict-of-interest disclosure.
- Until a reviewer signs off, the page says plainly that it is a draft.
- Safety alerts, recall listings and CHSA positions need two people: the person who writes it can’t be the person who approves it.
- Alerts that name a business are also reviewed by counsel.
- Every alert we publish is listed in our alert ledger. If it isn’t listed there, it isn’t from us.
Naming rules
Naming businesses and products
- We name a business, brand or product only when a regulator has named it in an official notice, such as a recall or enforcement action. We link to that notice.
- For counterfeits, we may name the real brand when a regulator or the brand owner confirms it, and we describe the brand as the victim.
- We never name anyone based on a tip, a social media post or a user report.
- We use the regulator’s own wording, and we update or remove the listing when the regulator does.
- Any business we name has a right of reply. It can reach us through our corrections page.
- Businesses tied to our directors, staff or funders get no special treatment. Alerts about them are published on the same terms as any other, with a disclosure line.
Naming people
- We say “cannabis” and “people who use cannabis.” We don’t use slang or labels that define people by drug use.
- We don’t name private individuals.
Words we avoid
Some words promise more than any product, store or law can deliver. We don’t use them.
| We don’t say | We say |
|---|---|
| safe (as an absolute) | lower-risk, less likely to, reduces the risk of |
| certified, approved, verified (of products or stores) | licensed by [regulator], tested by a licensed lab |
| clean, pure | passed required tests for [named contaminants] |
| premium, trusted brand | no substitute: we don’t rate brands |
Corrections
| Content | We acknowledge within | We correct or remove within |
|---|---|---|
| Safety alerts and recalls | 4 business hours | 24 hours |
| Everything else | — | 5 business days |
We don’t quietly edit mistakes away. Each correction is noted on the page and listed in our corrections log.